Reviewer Policy
Purpose and Scope
The e-Journal of Medical and Pharmaceutical Science (eJMPS) is committed to maintaining high standards of academic quality, scientific integrity, and ethical scholarly publishing. The journal follows a rigorous, fair, transparent, and confidential peer-review process to ensure that published articles meet appropriate scientific and academic standards.
This policy applies to all reviewers involved in evaluating manuscripts submitted to the journal, including original research articles, review articles, systematic reviews, case reports, short communications, and other scholarly contributions.
Peer-Review System
The journal follows a double-anonymized peer-review process, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process.
Each research manuscript considered for external peer review is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant subject expertise. Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, research experience, subject knowledge, and publication record.
The Editor-in-Chief makes the final editorial decision based on the reviewers' reports, the scientific quality of the manuscript, and the journal's editorial standards.
Selection and Appointment of Reviewers
Reviewers are selected from qualified researchers, academicians, clinicians, pharmacists, and subject specialists with relevant expertise in the manuscript's field.
The journal considers the following criteria when appointing reviewers:
- Relevant academic qualifications and subject expertise.
- Demonstrated research experience in the relevant discipline.
- A record of scholarly publications.
- Professional and ethical standing within the academic community.
- Independence from the authors and their affiliated institutions.
- Absence of financial, personal, professional, or other conflicts of interest.
Authors may suggest potential reviewers; however, the final selection and appointment of reviewers remain entirely at the discretion of the editorial team.
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, unbiased, and evidence-based assessments of submitted manuscripts.
Their responsibilities include:
- Evaluating the originality and scientific contribution of the manuscript.
- Assessing the relevance of the research to the journal's aims and scope.
- Examining the appropriateness of the research methodology and study design.
- Evaluating the accuracy and reliability of the results and interpretation.
- Assessing the quality of references and the relevance of cited literature.
- Identifying methodological weaknesses, inconsistencies, and unsupported conclusions.
- Evaluating ethical considerations, including research approval, informed consent, and participant protection, where applicable.
- Identifying possible plagiarism, duplicate publication, data manipulation, or other research misconduct.
- Providing clear recommendations and constructive suggestions for improvement.
Confidentiality and Anonymity
All manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents.
Reviewers must not:
- Share or distribute manuscripts or review materials without editorial permission.
- Use unpublished information or research findings for personal or professional advantage.
- Contact authors directly regarding a manuscript under review.
- Disclose the identity of authors or other reviewers.
- Discuss manuscript contents with unauthorized individuals.
The confidentiality of the peer-review process must be maintained before, during, and after publication.
Conflict of Interest
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest before accepting a review assignment.
A reviewer should decline the invitation if they:
- Have a close personal or professional relationship with any author.
- Have recently collaborated with any of the authors.
- Have financial or commercial interests related to the submitted research.
- Have institutional or academic relationships that may affect their impartiality.
- Have any other circumstances that could compromise their independent judgment.
The editorial team may appoint an alternative reviewer whenever a conflict of interest is identified.
Review Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers are requested to evaluate manuscripts according to the following criteria:
- Originality and novelty of the research.
- Scientific and academic significance.
- Relevance to the journal's scope.
- Clarity of research objectives and hypotheses.
- Appropriateness of methodology and study design.
- Accuracy of data analysis and interpretation.
- Quality of presentation, organization, and language.
- Adequacy and relevance of references.
- Compliance with research and publication ethics.
- Overall contribution to medical, pharmaceutical, and health sciences.
Reviewer Recommendations
Following evaluation, reviewers may recommend one of the following decisions:
Accept: The manuscript meets the journal's scientific and editorial requirements and requires no substantial revision.
Minor Revision: The manuscript requires limited corrections or clarifications before acceptance.
Major Revision: Significant improvements are required in methodology, analysis, interpretation, presentation, or other aspects.
Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's standards of scientific quality, originality, relevance, or ethical compliance.
Reviewers should provide sufficient justification for their recommendations. A recommendation from a reviewer does not constitute a final editorial decision.
Review Timeline
Reviewers are requested to complete their assessments within the timeframe communicated by the editorial office.
If additional time is required, reviewers should inform the editorial office promptly. If a reviewer is unable to complete the assignment, they should decline the invitation as early as possible.
The editorial team may appoint alternative reviewers to avoid unnecessary delays in the publication process.
Ethical Responsibilities and Research Integrity
Reviewers must adhere to recognized standards of publication ethics and research integrity, including applicable principles and guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE).
Reviewers should immediately inform the editorial office if they identify:
- Plagiarism or substantial text overlap.
- Duplicate or redundant publication.
- Fabrication or falsification of research data.
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest.
- Inappropriate authorship practices.
- Ethical concerns involving human participants or animals.
- Manipulation of images, tables, figures, or research findings.
Reviewers must provide relevant evidence or explanations whenever possible. All suspected cases of misconduct will be assessed by the editorial team in accordance with the journal's publication ethics and research misconduct policies.
Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) Tools
Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts, unpublished research data, or other confidential review materials to publicly accessible generative AI platforms or external AI services without explicit authorization and appropriate confidentiality safeguards.
AI tools must not replace the reviewer's independent scientific judgment. Reviewers remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, confidentiality, and integrity of their review reports.
Reviewers must disclose any permitted use of AI-assisted technologies to the editorial office when relevant to the review process.
Editorial Independence and Final Decision
All editorial decisions are made independently by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized handling editor.
Decisions are based on the scientific merit, originality, methodological quality, ethical compliance, and relevance of the manuscript.
The editorial team is not obligated to follow a reviewer's recommendation and may seek additional expert opinions whenever necessary.
Acceptance of a manuscript is never guaranteed, and editorial decisions are not influenced by authors' institutional affiliations, nationality, gender, personal relationships, or ability to pay publication charges.
Recognition of Reviewers
The journal values the voluntary academic contributions of its reviewers and recognizes their important role in maintaining publication quality.
The journal may provide reviewer acknowledgements, certificates of appreciation, or other appropriate recognition, subject to reviewer consent and confidentiality requirements.
Reviewer names and affiliations will not be disclosed without their permission, except where disclosure is part of an explicitly stated review model.
Review Appeals and Complaints
Reviewers may communicate concerns regarding the review process, editorial handling, or ethical issues directly to the editorial office.
Authors who disagree with an editorial decision may submit an appeal in accordance with the journal's Appeals and Complaints Policy. Appeals will be considered independently by the editorial team.
Policy Review and Updates
The journal reserves the right to revise this policy whenever necessary to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, publication ethics, and peer-review best practices.
Any updates will be published on the official journal website.